Freedom Can Feel Frightening When Bondage Was Familiar
There is a moment in the story of Israel that I think we can read too quickly.
God delivered them from Egypt.
The chains were gone. Pharaoh no longer owned them. They were no longer slaves. They had crossed the Red Sea, watched the waters close behind them, and stood on the other side as free people.
But being out of Egypt did not mean they immediately knew how to live as people who were free.
They had spent generations under someone else’s authority. Their lives had been structured around slavery. Their days, their labor, and much of what happened to them had been determined by someone else.
Then suddenly, everything changed.
They were free.
And freedom required something from them that bondage never had.
They had to learn how to live differently.
That may be one of the parts of deliverance we don’t talk about enough.
Sometimes God changes our circumstances before we have learned how to function in the new ones.
Sometimes the door opens before we feel prepared to walk through it.
Sometimes what we prayed for arrives, and instead of immediately feeling wonderful, it feels frightening.
Because freedom can feel frightening when bondage was familiar.
Leaving Something Is Not the Same as Unlearning It
When Israel walked out of Egypt, they left a geographical place.
But they carried years of experience with them.
They had learned how to survive in Egypt.
They had learned what to expect from Pharaoh. They had learned the rhythms of slavery. They had learned how to function inside a system they did not choose.
Those patterns did not disappear simply because their location changed.
We see evidence of that almost immediately.
When Pharaoh’s army approached them at the Red Sea, their first response wasn’t confidence.
It was fear.
They asked Moses:
“Is not this the word that we did tell thee in Egypt, saying, Let us alone, that we may serve the Egyptians?”— Exodus 14:12 KJV
Think about what they were saying.
Slavery suddenly sounded safer than uncertainty.
Not because slavery had become good.
Not because Pharaoh had become trustworthy.
Not because Egypt had somehow changed.
They were standing somewhere they had never stood before, facing something they did not know how to navigate.
And under that pressure, what they already knew how to survive began looking safer than what they had never experienced.
Sometimes We Carry the Old Place Into the New One
We can do this too.
A person can leave an unhealthy relationship and still carry the thought patterns developed inside it.
Someone can finally have permission to speak and still be afraid to use her voice.
Someone can leave an environment where she constantly had to defend herself and continue interpreting ordinary conversations as attacks.
Someone who spent years trying to keep everyone happy can finally establish healthy boundaries and then feel guilty every time she says no.
Someone can spend years believing her worth depends upon what she accomplishes and then struggle to rest even when no one is demanding anything from her.
The circumstances changed.
But the learned response remained.
That doesn’t necessarily mean the deliverance failed.
It may mean there is something else that now needs to be learned.
Sometimes we leave bondage before bondage leaves the way we think.
And perhaps that is part of why God didn’t simply bring Israel out of Egypt and immediately place them into the Promised Land.
There was something happening between those two places.
The Wilderness Was Also a Classroom
We often talk about the wilderness as though it were simply the unpleasant stretch between Egypt and Canaan.
But look at what God was doing there.
When they were hungry, they had to learn that God could provide manna.
When they were thirsty, they had to learn that God could provide water.
When enemies came against them, they had to learn that God could defend them.
When they didn’t know where to go, God led them.
When they needed instruction about how they were to live as His people, He gave them His commands.
Egypt had taught them how to live under Pharaoh.
The wilderness was teaching them how to live with God.
That is an entirely different way of understanding that season.
They weren’t simply wandering around waiting for something better.
They were learning.
They were discovering the character of the God who had delivered them.
They were learning dependence.
They were learning obedience.
They were learning trust.
They were learning identity.
They were learning how to become a people who belonged to God.
Freedom had a learning curve.
What If the Discomfort Doesn’t Mean You Made a Mistake?
This is where I think we need to be careful about how we interpret discomfort.
Sometimes discomfort is a warning.
There are situations we absolutely should pay attention to, and wisdom requires discernment.
But discomfort by itself does not automatically mean something is wrong.
Sometimes something feels uncomfortable because it is unfamiliar.
Imagine someone who has spent most of her life believing she has to explain every decision she makes.
Then she begins learning that she doesn’t have to defend herself constantly.
The first time she simply says, “No, I can’t do that,” and doesn’t provide a five-minute explanation, she may feel terrible afterward.
Why?
Did she do something wrong?
Maybe not.
Perhaps she simply did something new.
The old behavior felt comfortable because she had practiced it thousands of times.
The new behavior feels uncomfortable because she hasn’t.
The feeling of discomfort doesn’t necessarily tell her which behavior is healthier.
It may simply reveal which one is more familiar.
That distinction matters.
Familiarity Can Masquerade as Peace
Sometimes we say, “I just don’t have peace about this,” when what we actually mean is:
“I don’t feel comfortable doing this.”
Those are not always the same thing.
If God is asking us to forgive someone, that may not initially feel comfortable.
If we need to establish a boundary, that may not feel comfortable.
If we need to admit we were wrong, that may not feel comfortable.
If we are learning to stop controlling every outcome, that certainly may not feel comfortable.
If we are stepping into something we have never done before, our nervousness does not automatically mean God is warning us away from it.
We have to discern rather than allowing comfort alone to become our compass.
Israel could have interpreted Egypt as the safer choice because they knew what Egypt felt like.
But familiarity wasn’t evidence of God’s direction.
God was ahead of them.
Egypt was behind them.
You May Be Learning a New Response
There is another possibility when an old pattern starts pulling at us.
Maybe the issue isn’t simply resisting the old response.
Maybe we need to learn what replaces it.
If I have always responded to uncertainty by trying to control everything, what does trusting God actually look like?
If I have always responded to rejection by withdrawing, what does remaining emotionally present look like?
If I have always responded to mistakes by condemning myself, what does conviction without condemnation look like?
If I have always said yes because I was afraid someone would be disappointed in me, what does a healthy no look like?
If I have always measured my worth by productivity, what does rest look like when I no longer have to earn my value?
We can tell ourselves, “Stop doing the old thing,” all day long.
But freedom also asks:
“What does the new thing look like?”
That takes practice.
There may be awkwardness.
There may be mistakes.
There may be moments when we fall back into an old response simply because it is the response we know best.
That does not mean we should surrender and go back.
It means we keep learning.
Don’t Confuse Being a Beginner With Being in the Wrong Place
There is something humbling about being new at anything.
We like competence.
We like knowing what we’re doing.
We like knowing what happens next.
And sometimes an unhealthy place can provide something strangely appealing:
We know how to function there.
We may hate it.
We may know it isn’t good for us.
But we understand the rules.
Freedom can make us beginners again.
Now we have to learn different boundaries.
Different thoughts.
Different responses.
Different expectations.
Different ways of relating to people.
Different ways of relating to ourselves.
Sometimes even different ways of relating to God.
And beginners don’t always feel confident.
So perhaps you are not uncomfortable because you are in the wrong place.
Perhaps you are uncomfortable because you have never lived here before.
You know how to survive where you came from.
You are still learning how to live where you are.
God Was Teaching Israel Who They Were
Egypt had told Israel who they were.
Slaves.
Workers.
People whose value was connected to what they produced for Pharaoh.
But when God brought them out, He began speaking differently.
Before giving them His commandments at Sinai, God told them:
“Ye have seen what I did unto the Egyptians, and how I bare you on eagles’ wings, and brought you unto myself.”— Exodus 19:4 KJV
And then:
“Ye shall be unto me a kingdom of priests, and an holy nation.”— Exodus 19:6 KJV
Do you see the shift?
Pharaoh had defined them by what they could produce.
God defined them by whose they were.
That is a completely different identity.
And perhaps some of our greatest difficulty in freedom comes when God begins challenging identities we learned while we were surviving.
Maybe you learned:
I have to keep everyone happy.
I have to be useful to be valuable.
I can’t trust anyone.
I have to protect myself.
I have to control what happens next.
I have to prove myself.
I have to earn love.
Those beliefs may have helped you navigate a particular environment.
But that doesn’t mean they belong where God is taking you.
Freedom Is More Than an Open Door
God didn’t deliver Israel merely so they could say they weren’t in Egypt anymore.
He brought them out because He was bringing them to Himself.
That changes the way I think about freedom.
Freedom isn’t merely the absence of the thing that once held us.
It is learning how to live differently now that it no longer does.
It is discovering which thoughts belonged to Egypt.
Which reactions belonged to survival.
Which beliefs were formed under pressure.
Which behaviors made sense there but no longer belong here.
And then, little by little, learning another way.
So if freedom feels frightening right now, don’t immediately assume that fear means you made the wrong decision.
Ask another question:
“Am I in danger, or am I simply somewhere I have never learned how to live before?”
Those are very different things.
Under pressure, familiar bondage can sometimes feel safer than unfamiliar freedom.
And sometimes the place you know how to survive feels safer than the place where you have not yet learned how to live free.
But perhaps that is exactly what God is teaching you now.
Not merely how to leave what held you.
How to live free.
Much Love
~Gayla~
Continue Your Journey
If you’d like to spend more time in God’s Word, prayer, reflection, and spiritual growth, continue into The Secret Place, where you’ll find Bible studies, devotions, prayers, courses, The Garden Room, and resources designed to help you grow deeper in your relationship with God.
Continue into The Secret Place →
Continue Through My Books
If these reflections are helping you examine Scripture and your relationship with God through a deeper lens, I invite you to continue studying with me through my books and Bible studies.
Explore My Books →
Comments